Most event registration tools treat the ticket as the finish line. For a nonprofit it's the start. Here's what to look for, with the benchmarks to prove it.


You've probably lived through this campaign. Launch day goes well. Sign-ups pour in for a week, someone posts a screenshot of the counter in the team chat, and the mood is great. Then it goes quiet. Half the pages never get a donation, a handful of fundraisers carry the whole thing, and the final total lands well below the plan. In the evaluation meeting, someone says supporters just weren't engaged this year.
I've worked with peer-to-peer fundraising for about 14 years, and I think that explanation is usually wrong. Your supporters care, and the tools work. When a campaign underdelivers, the charity is most often pulling the wrong lever, or none at all. That's good news, because a broken lever can be found and fixed.
So let's find yours.
When a charity tells me it wants "more P2P fundraising", I start by splitting that wish into parts:
Total raised = (number of fundraisers × average raised per fundraiser) + self-donations
The average raised per fundraiser splits again: the share of fundraisers who become active, times the average donation size, times the average number of donations.
Why bother with the maths? Because each part is a separate lever, and different people hold them. The number of fundraisers belongs to the charity. Nobody else can make a supporter decide to fundraise for you; that ask has to come from you. The rest (how many sign-ups get going, how big the donations are, how many arrive) responds to stewardship, page design and small nudges.
Each of the six mistakes below breaks one part of the equation. If your peer-to-peer fundraising strategy is stuck, ask which lever is broken.
Asking someone to donate and asking someone to fundraise are two different requests. A donation ask runs on emotion: you show the need, the supporter feels it, and giving eases the feeling. A fundraising ask is a request to do something, and often something public and a little awkward.
That changes what motivates people. Loving the cause is nice to have. Being sold on the activity is need to have. A supporter who already loves you can become a brilliant fundraiser, but cause-love on its own rarely gets anyone off the sofa.
What does get people moving? Fun and social, first of all. Many of the strongest events make fundraising the entry ticket: you raise a minimum, and in return you join a group of like-minded people doing something memorable. Or take the simplest version. My mum signs up for a 5k walk and asks me to come. I'd never have joined on my own, but she asked, so I go. I could care very little about the cause and still say yes.
You can spot the cause-only approach by what I call the indignation trap. Outrage-driven campaigns (animal rights is the classic example) often get passionate supporters to create a page, and then nothing happens. With no activity and no occasion, the only move left is to cold-ask friends: "I believe in this, please support me." That turns your supporter into an unpaid street fundraiser, and there's a reason we normally pay people to do that job.
On top of fun and social sits the motivator I rate highest, and the one charities seem to use least: identity.
We all need to belong, and we all build our own identity. Fundraising helps with both. It's public by nature (you have to tell people you're doing it), and it ties you to a cause that stands for something. Add an activity, and you get another layer: this is who I am, and this is who I want people to see.
That should change how you recruit. P2P recruitment works best when it looks like perfume advertising. A perfume ad shows you someone you'd like to be, and the bottle is almost incidental. Show an admirable person doing the activity, then ask: do you want to be this person? I've gone deeper into this in why self-identity is important in P2P fundraising.
It also means your first fundraisers and ambassadors matter. If the faces on your campaign clash with the audience you want, these first fundraisers can actively put that audience off.
Even a motivated supporter needs an excuse to ask. With an occasion, asking friends feels natural; without one, it can feel like begging. The occasion packages the motivators above into a concrete thing to do.
The peer-to-peer fundraising campaigns that perform best tend to attach fundraising to things people already do. Here are six:
A campaign that asks people to "fundraise for us" and offers no occasion is relying on indignation. And as we've seen, indignation rarely follows through.
The number of fundraisers is the one lever only you control. So how much are you actually putting into it? For many charities, recruitment means one email to the database and a social post. That's a start, and it's rarely enough.
Smaller charities feel this most. Peer-to-peer fundraising needs a base to recruit from, and if yours is small, you'll probably need to pay to reach beyond it. Larger charities aren't off the hook either. In my experience, a dedicated ads budget aimed at your own supporters, and at people who look like them, is usually worth it even when your database is big. MSF Spain recruited just under 150 birthday fundraisers in about a month with Facebook ads that pointed to a chatbot, which then helped supporters set up their fundraiser.
Why do the numbers matter so much? Because results are heavily skewed. Across active fundraisers on BetterNow, the median raises €166. The 80th percentile raises €630, the 95th percentile €2,266, and the top 1% reach around €100,000. In our data, the top 1% can account for half or more of a charity's results. With 20 fundraisers, your total depends on whether one of them happens to be a star. With several hundred, you'll very likely find a few, and your income becomes something you can plan. (Our piece on forecasting P2P fundraising income shows how to budget for this.)
To be fair to the other side of the argument, ads come with three caveats:
One more thing before you open the floodgates: nobody wants to be the first name on an empty campaign page. Secure at least four active fundraisers before you launch broadly, so new visitors arrive to social proof.
This is the share-active lever, and in many campaigns it's where most of the potential leaks out.
Motivation peaks at the moment of sign-up. From there it fades, and if nothing reminds the fundraiser why they joined, it can fade to nothing. The page gets created with every good intention, and the sharing never happens.
The fix is a stewardship journey: planned messages that walk each fundraiser from sign-up to finish line. Five belong in every journey: a welcome, a check-in, a good-luck message before the event, a thank-you, and clear next steps afterwards. Our data points to about five opened stewardship emails as the magic number for fundraiser performance. Speed matters too, since donations in a fundraiser's first week are one of the strongest predictors of their final result.
For fundraisers who've gone quiet, a reactivation flow tends to pay for itself. In one stewardship case, a reactivation email journey brought back 44% of inactive fundraisers, with negligible unsubscribes. A single triggered email to inactive fundraisers reached an open rate above 57% and reactivated 17% of them. If you want a template to start from, our guide to communication plans for P2P fundraising has examples.
Two small asks change how much each active fundraiser raises.
First, the self-donation. Ask every fundraiser to make the first donation on their own page. In our data from over 33,000 fundraisers, those who self-donated were nearly three times as likely to reach their goal: 34% against 12.2%. Size counts as well. Self-donations below about €35–40 do little for donations from others, while larger ones lift them. A meaningful first gift shows commitment and sets the anchor for the friends who follow.
Second, the goal. Left to choose a number from scratch, fundraisers often pick a low one, or skip it. Jillian Stewart of Peerworks Consulting recommends a required minimum, then "banking on overperformance" against a suggested goal. Her example from a Danish event shows why. The minimum was 300 DKK and the old default goal was 3,000 DKK, a tenfold gap. Fundraisers set an average goal of 758 DKK and raised an average of 1,043 DKK, so they beat the target they chose. The charity then tested a more realistic default of 1,500 DKK. A sensible default goal gives people something to beat.
The last mistake is structural. Many charities run peer-to-peer fundraising as a string of one-off campaigns, with no clear owner, no agreed KPIs and no plan to bring this year's fundraisers back next year. So every campaign rebuilds its audience, its stories and its social proof from scratch.
Your best recruitment source is probably the people who fundraised for you last time. A programme with an owner, a memory and a plan for returning fundraisers compounds year on year. If this sounds familiar, read how to anchor P2P fundraising in your organisation and Scaling P2P: are you building a program or maintaining one?
Before your next campaign, run through these six questions. Each "no" points to the lever to fix first.
Lists of peer-to-peer fundraising best practices can run to dozens of tips. I'd start somewhere smaller: find the one lever that's broken and fix that first. Your supporters are willing to fundraise for you. Give them an activity worth doing, an occasion to ask, and the support to see it through, and you'll probably be surprised how generous their networks turn out to be.